RAP vs Refinancing: Which Saves You More?
Should you stay on the federal RAP plan or refinance with a private lender? RAP offers forgiveness and protections, while refinancing can lock in a lower rate. Enter your details below to see a personalized side-by-side comparison.
Enter Your Details
Refinancing Scenario
Check lenders to find your rate
RAP Monthly Payment
$166.67
4% of AGI
Total over 30 years: $60,001.20
Refinance Monthly Payment
$362.73
4.5% fixed for 10 years
Total over 10 years: $43,527.60
RAP saves you $196.06/month on monthly payments, but refinancing may cost less in total ($43.5k over 10 years vs. $60k over 30 years).
| Feature | RAP (Federal) | Refinancing (Private) |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly Payment | $166.67 | $362.73 |
| Total Paid Over Loan Life RAP: 30 years | Refinance: 10 years | $60,001.20 | $43,527.60 |
| Total Interest | $25,001.20 | $8,527.60 |
| Forgiveness Eligible Remaining balance forgiven after repayment period | Yes (after 30 years) | No |
| PSLF Eligible Public Service Loan Forgiveness after 10 years | Yes | No |
| Federal Protections Deferment, forbearance, income-driven options | Yes | No |
| Interest Subsidy Government prevents balance growth | Yes | No |
| Best For | Lower income, public service, uncertain future | High income, strong credit, want to pay off fast |
Ready to Check Your Refinancing Rate?
See how much you could save with a private lender. Check your personalized rate in minutes — it won't affect your credit score.
Check Your Rate with ELFI — Get $100 Off Your LoanYou'll receive a $100 principal reduction. We may receive a referral bonus at no cost to you.
When Should You Refinance?
Refinancing makes the most sense when you have strong, stable income and won't benefit from federal loan forgiveness programs. Specifically, consider refinancing if:
- ✓You have a high AGI (above $100k) where RAP charges 10% with no cap
- ✓You have excellent credit (720+) and can qualify for rates below your federal rate
- ✓You are NOT pursuing PSLF or other federal forgiveness programs
- ✓You have a stable career with low risk of income disruption
- ✓You want to pay off your loans faster with a fixed timeline
- ✓You have private loans mixed with federal (refinance only the private ones)
When Should You Stay on RAP?
RAP is typically the better choice when you value federal safety nets or expect to benefit from forgiveness. Keep your loans federal if:
- ✓You work in public service and are pursuing PSLF (10-year forgiveness)
- ✓Your income is low to moderate relative to your loan balance
- ✓You have a large loan balance that could be forgiven after 30 years
- ✓You value the $50/month government principal match
- ✓You need the interest subsidy to prevent your balance from growing
- ✓Your income may decrease (job change, returning to school, starting a family)
- ✓You want the safety net of federal deferment and forbearance options
Important: Refinancing federal loans into a private loan is irreversible. Once you refinance, you can never re-enroll in RAP, IBR, or any other federal income-driven plan. Make sure you fully understand what you're giving up before refinancing.
Not sure about your refinancing rate? Most lenders let you check in 2 minutes with no impact to your credit score.
Check Your Rate with ELFI →You'll receive a $100 principal reduction. We may receive a referral bonus at no cost to you.
Sources & Methodology
All calculations on this site are based on publicly available federal legislation and official government data. Our formulas are derived directly from the statutory text and are executed entirely in your browser — we never collect or store your financial information.
- ●P.L. 119-21 — One Big Beautiful Bill Act
RAP payment brackets, dependent deductions, interest subsidy rules, and forgiveness timeline are codified in this law. Read on Congress.gov →
- ●Federal Student Aid (studentaid.gov)
Official information on federal student loan programs, IDR plan eligibility, PSLF requirements, and loan consolidation. Visit studentaid.gov →
- ●2026 HHS Federal Poverty Guidelines
IBR calculations use the Federal Poverty Level published annually by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. Our calculators use the 2026 poverty guidelines for the contiguous 48 states. View HHS guidelines →
Calculator results are estimates only. Your actual payment may vary based on your loan servicer's implementation, recertification timing, and other factors. Always confirm with your servicer before making repayment decisions.